Judiciary Shifts Goalposts on ULS Appeals, Provokes Backlash and Accusations of Bias
By Adam Nuwamanya
The Uganda Law Society (ULS) has strongly protested the Judiciary’s removal of its appeals from the Court of Appeal cause list originally set for July 10, 2025. In a letter to the Deputy Chief Justice and Head of Court of Appeal Hon Dr Flavian Zeija signed by ULS Vice President Anthony Asiimwe, the Society on Friday July 4, 2025, called on the Judiciary to reinstate the scheduled hearings, while denouncing the Court of Appeal registrar for “bias and manipulation of the court.”
The removed appeals include:
- Civil Appeal No. 61 of 2025: ULS v Brian Kirima
- Civil Appeal No. 98 of 2025: ULS & Another v Mugisha Hashim & 2 Others
- Civil Appeal No. 99 of 2025: ULS & Another v Pheona Nabasa Gladys Wall
- Civil Appeal No. 102 of 2025: Isaac Kimaze Ssemakadde v Mugisha Hashim Mugisha
The Court of Appeal registrar HW Rukundo Allen Owembabazi on July 3, 2025, issued a letter stating that the matters had been “erroneously cause-listed” and would instead be redirected to “conferencing and hearing during the next convenient session.” The ULS expressed shock and disappointment, calling the move “procedurally flawed and legally indefensible.”
The Society contends that the Judiciary’s action contravenes Rule 20 of the Judicature (Court of Appeal) Rules, which gives judicial weight to the act of listing a matter for hearing and notifying parties of the Coram. ULS insists that such listing is a judicial act made under lawful delegation and “cannot be undone by the registry.”
ULS further disputes the Judiciary’s justification, rejecting the explanation that the listing was erroneous. They argue that the Court of Appeal’s hearing calendar is not provisional or subject to revision without lawful cause. “This is not a casual administrative appointment,” the statement reads.
Additionally, the ULS questions the legal basis for mandatory conferencing, referencing Civil Appeal No. 156 of 2013: Security Group (U) Ltd v Marie Stopes Uganda, where the Court of Appeal held that conferencing is not an essential step in the appeal process.
ULS emphasized that the affected appeals touch on critical constitutional and public interest matters, including:
- The Society’s mandate to nominate representatives to the 7th Judicial Service Commission,
- Internal democratic governance of the ULS,
- The liberty of its current president, and the ongoing deterioration of bar-bench relations.
The Society concludes that the Judiciary’s move appears aimed at frustrating ULS’s constitutional role and undermining judicial independence and transparency. In response, ULS has called on all its members to fill the Court of Appeal on July 10 2025 at 9:00AM, demanding that the appeals proceed as originally scheduled.